Legal Resource Center

Consent as a Defense to Defamation

 

Consent of the person who allegedly has been defamed is always a complete defense in the event of a defamation claim. The only Can consent be used as a reason for defamation? exception occurs when a person uses republication of defamatory material in order to determine the source of the original publication or to confirm its content or meaning. Although the person does make a request for the republication, such an honest inquiry aimed at identifying the source of defamatory remarks does not prevent that person’s successful defamation claim against that source.

Otherwise, the consent of the plaintiff provides absolute privilege to the publisher and bars all recovery in a defamation claim. Warr v. Jolly, 6 Car. & P. 497, 172 Eng.Rep. 1336 (1834); Borden, Inc. v. Wallace, 570 S.W.2d 445 (Tex.Civ.App. 1978).

 

Identifying Consent to Publication

A person may give consent by words, actions or by certain behavior, including inaction. A statement of consent does not have to be directly spoken or communicated to another, and it does not have to be written down in order to be considered valid.

It is enough that the consent is understood by or seems apparent to the publisher as determined by reasonable people based on the conduct of the plaintiff and the circumstances surrounding the publication. Brockman v. Detroit Diesel Allison Division, General Motors, (Ind.App.), 366 N.E.2d 1201 (1977).

The plaintiff does not have to know that the material he approved for publication is defamatory. If he knows the exact language of the publication or has reason to know that it could be defamatory and he gives consent, he is accepting the risk that it could be defamatory. Likewise, if a person participates in an activity, is part of an organization, or allows an investigation knowing the results of any of these will be reported, this constitutes consent and acceptance of the risk that the publication could be defamatory.

In giving consent, the plaintiff may determine the extent of the privilege given the publisher by setting limitations. If no limitations are set, privilege is absolute regardless of whether the publisher exhibits ill will or uses the material inappropriately. If limitations are set and publication is made outside of those limitations, the publisher does not have the plaintiff’s consent and recovery is not barred in the event of a claim. Royer v. Steinberg, 90 Cal.App.3d 490, 153 Cal. Rptr. 499 (1979)

Consent is not considered valid and cannot bar recovery if it is obtained fraudulently. Nor can a person give consent if he or she is under duress or does not have the capacity to give consent.

 

Conclusion

When considering a defamation claim, it is important to understand not only whether a person has given consent to a publication, but whether that consent has been given with limitations, including a specific time frame or a specific purpose. The attorneys at Minc Law, can help you determine how this rule applies to your situation. Contact them at (216) 373-7706.

Retainer vs. Flat Fee vs. Contingency – What Does It All Mean?

If you’re looking for a lawyer for an online defamation case or any other matter, one question may stand out among all the others: how does the lawyer get paid? Lawyers generally employ one of the following three pricing structures. Retainer (or "Hourly") Fee, Flat...

Guaranteed Defamation Removal From PredatorAlerts.co

Formerly known as ExposingJohns.com, PredatorAlerts.co is a popular site for users to expose predators & cheaters. If you’ve been falsely attacked on PredatorAlerts, it’s not too late to remove yourself & fake posts!

How to Remove Yourself & Complaints From BadGirlReports.Date

Have you been the victim of fake attacks & false complaints on BadGirlsReport.Date & want it removed as soon as possible? Find out how to remove yourself & defamatory posts from BadGirlReports.Date in this article!

Can I Put an Online Defamer in Jail? A Guide To U.S. Criminal Defamation & Libel Laws

Have you been defamed online & are wondering whether you can press charges against a person or put them in jail? Read on to learn which 14 U.S. states have criminal defamation laws & which legal remedies are best for you!

How Much Does a Defamation Lawyer Cost? The Cost to Sue for Internet Defamation

Have you been defamed or libeled on the Internet & are considering suing for Internet defamation? Learn more about how much it costs to sue for Internet defamation, attorney fee structures, & how much Minc Law charges.